Which album is better, Weezer's Pinkerton or the Blue Album. Lets compare track by track:

1. My Name Is Jonas vs Tired of Sex

Pinkerton, Tough one, T.O.S. kicks too much ass to deny B:0- P:1

2. No One Else vs Getchoo

Blue, we all have wanted a girl that will laugh for no one else B:1 – P:1

 3. The World Has Turned and Left Me Here vs No Other One

Blue. “World . .” wins this one in the last :52 seconds “Do You believe what I say now?”  B:2 – P: 1

 4. Buddy Holly vs Why Bother

Pinkerton, Buddy Holly, just over played, probably could have won this B:2 – P:2

 5. Undone -- The Sweater Song vs Across the Sea

Pinkerton, Across the Sea far too epic to lose this one B:2 – P:3

6. Surf Wax America vs The Good Life

Pinkerton, “Life” is so catchy and kick ass, Surf wax, kind of forgettable B:2 – P:4

7. Say It Ain't So vs El Scorcho

Blue, “Say it ain’t so” not only the high water mark for weezer, but maybe in 90s rock. B:3 – P:4

8. In the Garage vs Pink Triangle

Blue, for its eXcalibur reference (kitty pryde, nightcrawler too) ‘nuff said B:4 – P: 4

9. Holiday vs Falling for You

Pinkerton. Almost gave this to Holiday for the acapella break down, but couldn’t do it. Falling for you is better.  B:4 – P:5

 10. Only in Dreams vs Butterfly

Blue gets two points for Only in Dreams DESTROYING this wussy acoustic album ender. B:6 – P:5

Blue Wins!!!!!

Glad I could finally end this great controversy.